百科问答小站 logo
百科问答小站 font logo



审稿意见怎么回复?需要注意什么? 第1页

  

user avatar   da-kou-ge-31 网友的相关建议: 
      

开头先感谢一下审稿人:

Dear reviewers,

Thank you very much for your kindly comments on our manuscript. There is no doubt that these comments are valuable and very helpful for revising and improving our manuscript. In what follows, we would like to answer the questions you mentioned and give detailed account of the changes made to the original manuscript.

回复审稿意见时经常会遇到以下几种情况:

  1. 审稿人让你引用某些文章。回复:Thank you for your introduction to these wonderful research work. According to your suggestion, we properly cite these articles as:
  2. 审稿人挑了一些语法问题,并让你好好检查一下。回复:Thank you for your significant reminding. According to your suggestion, we corrected the above grammatical errors and made an effort to correct the spelling and grammar errors and polish the whole manuscript. We would like to confirm that the suitably revised manuscript is understandable to readers.

回复完所有意见后,最后再感谢一下审稿人:

Thank you again for your positive and constructive comments and suggestions on our manuscript.

We hope you will find our revised manuscript acceptable for publication.

点对点回复时首先感谢审稿人提的建议,由于意见较多,可以有以下几种感谢句式:

  • Thanks for your valuable counsel.
  • Thank you for pointing this out.
  • Thank you for your significant reminding.

最后,上传修改稿时会给编辑写一封Cover letter (或者叫做Revision letter,或Resubmission letter),主要目的是向编辑说明我们做了哪些修改。

格式如下:

Dear Prof. 编辑的名字,


On behalf of my co-authors, we thank you very much for giving us an opportunity to revise our manuscript, we appreciate the reviewers very much for their positive and constructive comments and suggestions on our manuscript entitled “手稿标题”. (Manuscript ID: ####).

We study the comments carefully and make revision which we hope meet with approval.

According to the reviewers' comments,

1) We described the role of the *****.

2) We explained the ***.

The main revision in the paper and the response to the reviewers' comments are detailedly indicated in the attached file “Responses to comments”, and all changes are also highlighted in the attached PDF “marked-up version”.

We hope you will find our revised manuscript acceptable for publication.

Yours sincerely,

***

觉得有用的朋友可以关注我,后面我会更新!




  

相关话题

  如何看待中南大学 92 年特聘教授齐冲冲,3 年博士期间发表 40 篇 SCI? 
  如何看待马毅老师深度学习第一性原理的文章在 ICML 四个审稿人一致接收的情况下被 AC 拒了? 
  同样是985大学的博士生,为什么有的博士生能发几篇SCI,而有的一篇核心也发不了? 
  河南一校长发表熟蛋返生孵雏鸡论文,称利用特异学生意念和能量传播,为什么该论文能发表?暴露了哪些问题? 
  李家洋院士称「只认第一作者,还怎么鼓励合作」,也有人担心水论文,你认为哪种对科研发展更有利? 
  导师让我帮低年级的师弟师妹改期刊论文,我是否可以要求论文加我名字呢,应该找谁说,怎么说比较合适? 
  投稿后,审稿审了3个月是什么什么情况? 
  投期刊返修写Response的时候,应该写详细一些还是简要点? 
  你在学术论文投稿时遇到过评价最好的审稿意见是什么? 
  如何顺利发表一篇科学引文索引(SCI)文章? 

前一个讨论
有人用过工业路由器吗?哪个牌子的靠谱?
下一个讨论
2021年人工智能领域有哪些关键性进展和突破?





© 2025-02-22 - tinynew.org. All Rights Reserved.
© 2025-02-22 - tinynew.org. 保留所有权利