战列舰对轰，二战日本海军能战胜英国吗？ 第1页

不谢邀，并不是很想答这种东西

简单说两条

1.假设打起来，IJN大概率死于雷击。日本巡洋舰部队从职能上讲，反雷击这方面是严重欠缺的，既缺乏装备又缺乏意识。痴迷远距离交战的结果是，居然指望战列线中靠前的战列舰在30km以上距离开火来支援前出的重巡队，雷击距离也是完全不切实际。英国人的打法是，雷击队快速接敌、近距离雷击，且可以用鱼雷攻击适合的任意目标（包括对方雷击舰），轻巡在雷击队身后压制对方雷击舰，战巡在轻巡身后压制对方支援兵力。距离都是很近的，位置最远的战巡基本上两万码也就开火了，日方只有重巡+雷击队的前卫队完全无力对抗。之后就是英国雷击舰队在轻巡和战巡的支援下骑到日本战列舰队的脸上，虽然日本主力舰反雷击能力说不上差，但主力舰反雷击怎么说也是最后一道防线了。这里面有没有大和型都无所谓，因为她的位置无论如何都没理由在金刚型的前面。

2.实际上怎么也打不起来。无非就两种情况：要么日本人不发动陆上进攻，则IJN无力在东南亚维持大型战列舰队的存在，那么RN继续新加坡战略，保留少量高速兵力即可；要么史实情况日本占领法属印支，从而能成功攻击新加坡，那么RN退守锡兰，IJN的问题还是一样——无力把大型舰队派往印度洋。无论是哪种情况，IJN必然都是优先调动航空舰队，最有可能碰上RN主力舰的是金刚型，而非大和型。

————————

不想挂人，但评论区的某几位，大概看都没看过英美日相关的作战条令吧，哪来的勇气在这叽歪

RN的相关条令：

THE BATTLEFLEET ACTION

226. If the battlefleets can be brought to action, the Admiral will rely on the offensive powers of all surface vessels and aircraft to deal the enemy battlefleet a heavy blow in the first stage of the action. The fleet will be manoeuvred with the battleship divisions in close mutual support, and the range will be closed until decisive results may be expected. In order to obtain effective results at long range, the fire of battleships will be concentrated on a few of the enemy's ships. As the range decreases, the degree of concentration will be lessened until ship for ship actions are effective. At the same time, the enemy battlefleet will be attacked with torpedoes from light craft and air striking forces. By resolute fighting the initial pressure will be increased, until the enemy weakens and finally falls into confusion or retreat.

TORPEDO ATTACK

227. Long range torpedo attack will seldom achieve results against single enemy squadrons, with high speed and freedom of manoeuvre. Opportunities for firing torpedoes at medium and short ranges seldom recur and should not be missed. Though a massed destroyer attack may be ordered when the two battlefleets have become fully engaged, destroyers may expect opportunities for torpedo attack at all stages of a fleet action. The aim of all Senior Officers of destroyer units should be to fire torpedoes to hit from a close range.